gstreamer/docs/random/draft-missing-plugins.txt

What to do when a plugin is missing
===================================

We only discuss playback pipelines for now.

A three step process:

1) gstreamer level

 - a new GstMessage type to report missing plugins:

  GST_MESSAGE_MISSING_PLUGIN
   type: (string) { "urisource", "urisink", "decoder", "encoder", "element", ...
   detail: (string) { ANY }    ex: "mms, "mmsh", "audio/x-mp3,rate=48000,..."
   name: (string) { ANY }      ex: "MMS protocol handler",..   

  =====> FIXME: really add a message type? Why not an element message? <=====

 - missing uri handler 
  
  ex. mms://foo.bar/file.asf

  When no protocol handler is installed for mms://, the application will not be
  able to instantiate an element for that uri (gst_element_make_from_uri()
  returns NULL).

  Playbin will post a GST_MESSAGE_MISSING_PLUGIN message with the type set to 
  "urisource", detail set to "mms". Optionally the friendly name can be filled
  in as well.

 - missing typefind function

  We don't recognize the type of the file, this should normally not happen
  because all the typefinders are in the basic gstreamer installation.
  There is not much useful information we can give about how to resolve this 
  issue. It is possible to use the first N bytes of the data to determine the
  type (and needed plugin) on the server. We don't explore this option in this
  document yet, but the proposal is flexible enough to accomodate this in the
  future should the need arise.

 - missing demuxer

  Typically after running typefind on the data we determine the type of the 
  file. If there is no plugin found for the type, a GST_MESSAGE_PLUGIN_MISSING
  is posted by decodebin with the following fields: Type set to "decoder",
  detail set to the caps for witch no plugin was found. Optionally the friendly
  name can be filled in as well.

 - missing decoder 

  The demuxer will dynamically create new pads with specific caps while it 
  figures out the contents of the container format. Decodebin tries to find the
  decoders for these formats in the registry. If there is no decoder found, a
  MISSING_PLUGIN is posted by decodebin with the following fields: Type set to
  "decoder", detail set to the caps for which no plugin was found. Optionally
  the friendly name can be filled in as well. There is no distinction made
  between the missing demuxer and decoder at the application level.

 - missing element

  Decodebin and playbin will create a set of helper elements when they set up
  their decoding pipeline. These elements are typically colorspace, sample rate,
  audio sinks,... Their presence on the system is required for the functionality
  of decodebin. It is typically a package dependency error if they are not
  present but in case of a corrupted system the following PLUGIN_MISSING message
  will be emitted: type set to "element", detail set to the element factory name
  and the friendly name optionally set to a description of the element's
  functionality in the decoding pipeline.

 Except for reported the missing plugins, no further policy is enforced at the
 gstreamer level. It is up to the application to decide whether a missing
 plugin constitutes a problem or not.

 In addition, a thin callback API will be added to GStreamer to initiate
 plugin download and receive feedback about whether the plugin download
 succeeded (in full or partially) or failed.

   struct GstMissingPluginHandler {
     /* This function must be blocking; the function is implemented by an
      * external library (chosen by the application) */
     gboolean (*install_plugins) (const gchar ** missing_ids, GError ** error);

     /*< private >*/
     gpointer   padding[GST_PADDING];
   };

   typedef void (GstMissingPluginInstallResultFunc *) (const GError * error,
                                                       gpointer       user_data);

   /* The GstMissingPluginHandler struct is provided by some helper library
    * which implements the IPC details; this function does not block and will
    * return immediately; the result_callback function will be called when the
    * IPC implementation has finished (this might happen from the context of
    * another thread, it is the responsibility of the application to take care
    * of locking or marshalling the result back into the main thread in a
    * thread-safe manner */
   gboolean gst_install_missing_plugins (const GstMissingPluginHandler    * handler,
                                         GList                            * messages,
                                         GstMissingPluginInstallResultFunc  result_callback,
                                         gpointer                           result_callback_data,
                                         GError                          ** error);

    =====> FIXME: progress function? (+ make API better) <=========

  gst_install_missing_plugins() takes a GList of PLUGIN_MISSING messages and
  a GstMissingPluginHandler structure which specifies the implementation of
  the IPC mechanism. It will transform each PLUGIN_MISSING message into an
  ID string that among other things identifies the type of missing capability.
  Mapping this ID to packages and downloading and installing packages is the
  responsibility of the external IPC system.

  The gst_install_missing_plugins() callback will initiate a re-scan
  of the available plugins before calling the result_callback with a
  positive result.


  Format of the (UTF-8) string ID passed to the external installer system:
    The string is made up of several fields, separated by '|' characters.
    The fields are:

      - plugin system identifier, ie. gstreamer.net
      - plugin system version, e.g. 0.10
      - application identifier, e.g. totem
      - human-readable localised description of the required component,
        e.g. "Vorbis audio decoder"
      - identifier string for the required component, e.g.
           - urisource-$(PROTOCOL_REQUIRED)
               e.g. urisource-http or urisource-mms
           - element-$(ELEMENT_REQUIRED),
               e.g. element-ffmpegcolorspace
           - decoder-$(CAPS_REQUIRED)
               e.g. decoder-audio/x-vorbis or decoder-application/ogg
           - encoder-$(CAPS_REQUIRED)
               e.g. encoder-audio/x-vorbis

    An entire ID string might then look like this, for example:

      gstreamer.net|0.10|totem|Vorbis audio decoder|decoder-audio/x-vorbis
 
    The human-readable description string will come from a new utility
    library that yet to be added to gst-plugins-base and which can then also
    be used by demuxers to find out the codec names for taglists from given
    caps in a unified and consistent way.



2) application level

 The application's job is to listen for the MISSING_PLUGIN messages and to
 decide on a policy to handle them.

 - partially missing plugins

 The application will be able to complete a state change to PAUSED but there 
 will be a MISSING_PLUGIN message on the GstBus. 

 This means that it will be possible to play back part of the media file but not
 all of it. 

 For example: suppose we have an .avi file with mp3 audio and divx video. If we 
 have the mp3 audio decoder but not the divx video decoder, it will be possible
 to play only the audio part but not the video part. For an audio playback
 application, this is not a problem but a video player might want to decide on:

   - require the use to install the additionally required plugins. 
   - inform the user that only the audio will be played back
   - ask the user if it should download the additional codec or only play the 
     audio part.
   - ...

 - completely unplayable stream

 The application will receive an ERROR message from gstreamer informing it that
 playback stopped (before it could reach PAUSED).

 The application can then see that there are a set of MISSING_PLUGIN messages on
 the GstBus and can decide to trigger the download procedure. It does that
 by calling gst_install_missing_plugins() which is documented above, passing
 the MISSING_PLUGIN messages collected.