gstreamer/docs/design/draft-latency.txt

Latency
-------

The latency is the time it takes for a sample captured at timestamp 0 to reach the
sink. This time is measured against the clock in the pipeline. For pipelines
where the only elements that synchronize against the clock are the sinks, the
latency is always 0 since no other element is delaying the buffer.

For pipelines with live sources, a latency is introduced, mostly because of the
way a live source works. Consider an audio source, it will start capturing the
first sample at time 0. If the source pushes buffers with 44100 samples at a
time at 44100Hz it will have collected the buffer at second 1.
Since the timestamp of the buffer is 0 and the time of the clock is now >= 1
second, the sink will drop this buffer because it is too late.
Without any latency compensation in the sink, all buffers will be dropped.

The situation becomes more complex in the presence of:

 - 2 live sources connected to 2 live sinks with different latencies
    * audio/video capture with synchronized live preview.
    * added latencies due to effects (delays, resamplers...)
 - 1 live source connected to 2 live sinks
    * firewire DV
    * RTP, with added latencies because of jitter buffers.
 - mixed live source and non-live source scenarios.
    * synchronized audio capture with non-live playback. (overdubs,..)
 - clock slaving in the sinks due to the live sources providing their own
   clocks.

To perform the needed latency corrections in the above scenarios, we must
develop an algorithm to calculate a global latency for the pipeline. The
algorithm must be extensible so that it can optimize the latency at runtime. 
It must also be possible to disable or tune the algorithm based on specific
application needs (required minimal latency).


Pipelines without latency compensation
--------------------------------------

We show some examples to demonstrate the problem of latency in typical
capture pipelines.

- Example 1

  An audio capture/playback pipeline.

   asrc: audio source, provides a clock
   asink audio sink, provides a clock

   .--------------------------.
   | pipeline                 |
   | .------.      .-------.  |
   | | asrc |      | asink |  |
   | |     src -> sink     |  |
   | '------'      '-------'  |
   '--------------------------'

 NULL->READY:
  asink: NULL->READY: probes device, returns SUCCESS 
  asrc: NULL->READY:  probes device, returns SUCCESS

 READY->PAUSED:
  asink: READY:->PAUSED open device, returns ASYNC 
  asrc: READY->PAUSED:  open device, returns NO_PREROLL

  * Since the source is a live source, it will only produce data in the
    PLAYING state. To note this fact, it returns NO_PREROLL from the state change
    function.
  * This sink returns ASYNC because it can only complete the state change to
    PAUSED when it receives the first buffer.

  At this point the pipeline is not processing data and the clock is not
  running. Unless a new action is performed on the pipeline, this situation will
  never change.

 PAUSED->PLAYING:
  asrc clock selected because it is the most upstream clock provider. asink can
  only provide a clock when it received the first buffer and configured the
  device with the samplerate in the caps.

  asink: PAUSED:->PLAYING, sets pending state to PLAYING, returns ASYNC becaus
                         it is not prerolled. The sink will commit state to
			 PLAYING when it prerolls.
  asrc: PAUSED->PLAYING: starts pushing buffers.

  * since the sink is still performing a state change from READY -> PAUSED, it
    remains ASYNC. The pending state will be set to PLAYING.
  * The clock starts running as soon as all the elements have been set to
    PLAYING.
  * the source is a live source with a latency. Since it is synchronized with
    the clock, it will produce a buffer with timestamp 0 and duration D after
    time D, ie. it will only be able to produce the last sample of the buffer
    (with timestamp D) at time D. This latency depends on the size of the
    buffer.
  * the sink will receive the buffer with timestamp 0 at time >= D. At this
    point the buffer is too late already and might be dropped. This state of
    constantly dropping data will not change unless a constant latency
    correction is added to the incomming buffer timestamps.

  The problem is due to the fact that the sink is set to (pending) PLAYING
  without being prerolled, which only happens in live pipelines. 

- Example 2

  An audio/video capture/playback pipeline. We capture both audio and video and
  have them played back synchronized again.

   asrc: audio source, provides a clock
   asink audio sink, provides a clock
   vsrc: video source
   vsink video sink

   .--------------------------.
   | pipeline                 |
   | .------.      .-------.  |
   | | asrc |      | asink |  |
   | |     src -> sink     |  |
   | '------'      '-------'  |
   | .------.      .-------.  |
   | | vsrc |      | vsink |  |
   | |     src -> sink     |  |
   | '------'      '-------'  |
   '--------------------------'

  The state changes happen in the same way as example 1. Both sinks end up with
  pending state of PLAYING and a return value of ASYNC until they receive the
  first buffer.

  For audio and video to be played in sync, both sinks must compensate for the
  latency of its source but must also use exactly the same latency correction.  

  Suppose asrc has a latency of 20ms and vsrc a latency of 33ms, the total
  latency in the pipeline has to be at least 33ms. This also means that the
  pipeline must have at least a 33 - 20 = 13ms buffering on the audio stream or
  else the audio src will underrun while the audiosink waits for the previous
  sample to play.

- Example 3

  An example of the combination of a non-live (file) and a live source (vsrc) 
  connected to live sinks (vsink, sink). 

   .--------------------------.
   | pipeline                 |
   | .------.      .-------.  |
   | | file |      | sink  |  |
   | |     src -> sink     |  |
   | '------'      '-------'  |
   | .------.      .-------.  |
   | | vsrc |      | vsink |  |
   | |     src -> sink     |  |
   | '------'      '-------'  |
   '--------------------------'

  The state changes happen in the same way as example 1. Except sink will be
  able to preroll (commit its state to PAUSED).

  In this case sink will have no latency but vsink will. The total latency
  should be that of vsink.

  Note that because of the presence of a live source (vsrc), the pipeline can be
  set to playing before sink is able to preroll. Without compensation for the
  live source, this might lead to synchronisation problems because the latency
  should be configured in the element before it can go to PLAYING.


- Example 4

  An example of the combination of a non-live and a live source. The non-live
  source is connected to a live sink and the live source to a non-live sink.

   .--------------------------.
   | pipeline                 |
   | .------.      .-------.  |
   | | file |      | sink  |  |
   | |     src -> sink     |  |
   | '------'      '-------'  |
   | .------.      .-------.  |
   | | vsrc |      | files |  |
   | |     src -> sink     |  |
   | '------'      '-------'  |
   '--------------------------'

  The state changes happen in the same way as example 3. Sink will be
  able to preroll (commit its state to PAUSED). files will not be able to
  preroll.

  sink will have no latency since it is not connected to a live source. files
  does not do synchronisation so it does not care about latency.

  The total latency in the pipeline is 0. The vsrc captures in sync with the
  playback in sink.

  As in example 3, sink can only be set to PLAYING after it successfully
  prerolled.


State Changes revised
---------------------

As a first step in a generic solution we propose to modify the state changes so
that no sink is set to PLAYING before it is prerolled.

In order to do this, the pipeline (at the GstBin level) keeps track of all
elements that require preroll (the ones that return ASYNC from the state
change). These elements posted a ASYNC_START message without a matching
ASYNC_DONE message.

The pipeline will not change the state of the elements that are still doing an
ASYNC state change.

When an ASYNC element prerolls, it commits its state to PAUSED and posts an
ASYNC_DONE message. The pipeline notices this ASYNC_DONE message and matches it
with the ASYNC_START message it cached for the corresponding element. 

When all ASYNC_START messages are matched with an ASYNC_DONE message, the
pipeline proceeds with setting the elements to the final state again.

The base time of the element was already set by the pipeline when it changed the
NO_PREROLL element to PLAYING. This operation has to be performed in the
separate async state change thread (like the one currently used for going from
PAUSED->PLAYING in a non-live pipeline).

implications:

 - the current async_play vmethod in basesink can be deprecated since we now
   always call the state change function when going from PAUSED->PLAYING. We
   keep this method however to remain backward compatible.


Latency compensation
--------------------

As an extension to the revised state changes we can perform latency calculation
and compensation before we proceed to the PLAYING state. 

When the pipeline collected all ASYNC_DONE messages it can calculate the global
latency as follows:

  - perform a latency query on all sinks.
  - latency = MAX (all min latencies) 
  - if MIN (all max latencies) < latency we have an impossible situation and we
    must generate an error indicating that this pipeline cannot be played. This
    usually means that there is not enough buffering in some chain of the
    pipeline. A queue can be added to those chains.

The sinks gather this information with a LATENCY query upstream. Intermediate
elements pass the query upstream and add the amount of latency they add to the
result.

ex1:
  sink1: [20 - 20]
  sink2: [33 - 40]

  MAX (20, 33) = 33
  MIN (20, 40) = 20 < 33 -> impossible

ex2:
  sink1: [20 - 50]
  sink2: [33 - 40]

  MAX (20, 33) = 33
  MIN (50, 40) = 40 >= 33 -> latency = 33

The latency is set on the pipeline by sending a LATENCY event to the sinks
in the pipeline. This event configures the total latency on the sinks. The
sink forwards this LATENCY event upstream so that intermediate elements can
configure themselves as well.

After this step, the pipeline continues setting the pending state on its
elements.

A sink adds the latency value, received in the LATENCY event, to
the times used for synchronizing against the clock. This will effectively
delay the rendering of the buffer with the required latency. Since this delay is
the same for all sinks, all sinks will render data relatively synchronised.


Flushing a playing pipeline
---------------------------

Using the new state change mechanism we can implement resynchronisation after an
uncontrolled FLUSH in (part of) a pipeline. Indeed, when a flush is performed on
a PLAYING live element, a new base time must be distributed to this element.

A flush in a pipeline can happen in the following cases:

 - flushing seek in the pipeline
    - performed by the application on the pipeline
    - performed by the application on an element
 - flush preformed by an element
    - after receiving a navigation event (DVD, ...)

When a playing sink is flushed by a FLUSH_START event, an ASYNC_START  message is
posted by the element. As part of the message, the fact that the element got
flushes is included. The element also goes to a pending PAUSED state and has to
be set to the PLAYING state again later.

The ASYNC_START message is kept by the parent bin. When the element prerolls,
it posts an ASYNC_DONE message. 

When all ASYNC_START messages are matched with an ASYNC_DONE message, the bin
will capture a new base_time from the clock and will bring all the sinks back to
PLAYING after setting the new base time on them. It's also possible
to perform additional latency calculations and adjustments before doing this. 


Dynamically adjusting latency
-----------------------------

An element that want to change the latency in the pipeline can do this by
posting a LATENCY message on the bus. This message instructs the pipeline to:

 - query the latency in the pipeline (which might now have changed) with a
   LATENCY query.
 - redistribute a new global latency to all elements with a LATENCY event.

A use case where the latency in a pipeline can change could be a network element
that observes an increased inter packet arrival jitter or excessive packet loss
and decides to increase its internal buffering (and thus the latency). The
element must post a LATENCY message and perform the additional latency
adjustments when it receives the LATENCY event from the downstream peer element.

In a similar way can the latency be decreased when network conditions are
improving again.

Latency adjustments will introduce glitches in playback in the sinks and must
only be performed in special conditions.