diff --git a/migrations/2024-04-05-153647_alter_vote_display_mode_defaults/up.sql b/migrations/2024-04-05-153647_alter_vote_display_mode_defaults/up.sql
index b270bacbb..f98012713 100644
--- a/migrations/2024-04-05-153647_alter_vote_display_mode_defaults/up.sql
+++ b/migrations/2024-04-05-153647_alter_vote_display_mode_defaults/up.sql
@@ -8,3 +8,13 @@ ALTER TABLE local_user_vote_display_mode
     ALTER COLUMN score SET DEFAULT FALSE,
     ALTER COLUMN upvote_percentage SET DEFAULT FALSE;
 
+-- Regenerate the rows with the new default
+DELETE FROM local_user_vote_display_mode;
+
+-- Re-insert them
+INSERT INTO local_user_vote_display_mode (local_user_id)
+SELECT
+    id
+FROM
+    local_user;
+