diff --git a/bookwyrm/importer.py b/bookwyrm/importer.py
index b6e959cb3..a12884007 100644
--- a/bookwyrm/importer.py
+++ b/bookwyrm/importer.py
@@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ class Importer:
     service = 'Unknown'
     delimiter = ','
     encoding = 'UTF-8'
-    mandatory_fields = ['ISBN13', 'Title', 'Author']
+    mandatory_fields = ['Title', 'Author']
 
     def create_job(self, user, csv_file, include_reviews, privacy):
         ''' check over a csv and creates a database entry for the job'''
@@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ class Importer:
         )
         for index, entry in enumerate(list(csv.DictReader(csv_file, delimiter=self.delimiter ))):
             if not all(x in entry for x in self.mandatory_fields):
-                raise ValueError('Author, title, and isbn must be in data.')
+                raise ValueError('Author and title must be in data.')
             entry = self.parse_fields(entry)
             self.save_item(job, index, entry)
         return job
diff --git a/bookwyrm/librarything_import.py b/bookwyrm/librarything_import.py
index 019573acb..0584daad9 100644
--- a/bookwyrm/librarything_import.py
+++ b/bookwyrm/librarything_import.py
@@ -12,8 +12,8 @@ class LibrarythingImporter(Importer):
     service = 'LibraryThing'
     delimiter = '\t'
     encoding = 'ISO-8859-1'
-    # mandatory_fields : fields matching the book ISBN13, title and author
-    mandatory_fields = ['ISBN', 'Title', 'Primary Author']
+    # mandatory_fields : fields matching the book title and author
+    mandatory_fields = ['Title', 'Primary Author']
 
     def parse_fields(self, initial):
         data = {}
@@ -23,7 +23,10 @@ class LibrarythingImporter(Importer):
         data['Author'] = initial['Primary Author']
         data['ISBN13'] = initial['ISBN']
         data['My Review'] = initial['Review']
-        data['My Rating'] = math.ceil(float(initial['Rating']))
+        if initial['Rating']:
+            data['My Rating'] = math.ceil(float(initial['Rating']))
+        else:
+            data['My Rating'] = ''
         data['Date Added'] = re.sub('\[|\]', '', initial['Entry Date'])
         data['Date Started'] = re.sub('\[|\]', '', initial['Date Started'])
         data['Date Read'] = re.sub('\[|\]', '', initial['Date Read'])
diff --git a/bookwyrm/templates/import.html b/bookwyrm/templates/import.html
index dd60ebff6..a7fde76df 100644
--- a/bookwyrm/templates/import.html
+++ b/bookwyrm/templates/import.html
@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@
           <p>Data source</p>
         <div class="select {{ class }}">
           <select name="source" id="source">
-            <option value="GoodReads" {% if current == 'LibraryThing' %}selected{% endif %}>
+            <option value="GoodReads" {% if current == 'GoodReads' %}selected{% endif %}>
             GoodReads
             </option>
             <option value="LibraryThing" {% if current == 'LibraryThing' %}selected{% endif %}>
diff --git a/bookwyrm/tests/data/librarything.tsv b/bookwyrm/tests/data/librarything.tsv
index f0dca77fb..a707f2a9b 100644
--- a/bookwyrm/tests/data/librarything.tsv
+++ b/bookwyrm/tests/data/librarything.tsv
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
 Book Id	Title	Sort Character	Primary Author	Primary Author Role	Secondary Author	Secondary Author Roles	Publication	Date	Review	Rating	Comment	Private Comment	Summary	Media	Physical Description	Weight	Height	Thickness	Length	Dimensions	Page Count	LCCN	Acquired	Date Started	Date Read	Barcode	BCID	Tags	Collections	Languages	Original Languages	LC Classification	ISBN	ISBNs	Subjects	Dewey Decimal	Dewey Wording	Other Call Number	Copies	Source	Entry Date	From Where	OCLC	Work id	Lending Patron	Lending Status	Lending Start	Lending End
 5498194	Marelle	1	Cortázar, Julio				Gallimard (1979), Poche	1979	chef d'oeuvre	4.5			Marelle by Julio Cortázar (1979)	Broché	590 p.; 7.24 inches	1.28 pounds	7.24 inches	1.26 inches	4.96 inches	7.24 x 4.96 x 1.26 inches	590 			[2007-04-16]	[2007-05-08]			roman, espagnol, expérimental, bohème, philosophie	Your library	French	Spanish	PQ7797 .C7145	[2070291340]	2070291340, 9782070291342	Cort�azar, Julio. Rayuela	863	Literature > Spanish And Portuguese > Spanish fiction		1	Amazon.fr	[2006-08-09]			57814				
 5015319	Le grand incendie de Londres: Récit, avec incises et bifurcations, 1985-1987 (Fiction & Cie)	1	Roubaud, Jacques				Seuil (1989), Unknown Binding	1989		5			Le grand incendie de Londres: Récit, avec incises et bifurcations, 1985-1987 (Fiction & Cie) by Jacques Roubaud (1989)	Broché	411 p.; 7.72 inches	0.88 pounds	7.72 inches	1.02 inches	5.43 inches	7.72 x 5.43 x 1.02 inches	411 								Your library	English		PQ2678 .O77	[2020104725]	2020104725, 9782020104722	Autobiographical fiction|Roubaud, Jacques > Fiction	813	American And Canadian > Fiction > Literature		1	Amazon.com	[2006-07-25]			478910				
-5015399	Le Maître et Marguerite	1	Boulgakov, Mikhaïl				Pocket (1994), Poche	1994		5			Le Maître et Marguerite by Mikhaïl Boulgakov (1994)	Broché	579 p.; 7.09 inches	0.66 pounds	7.09 inches	1.18 inches	4.33 inches	7.09 x 4.33 x 1.18 inches	579 								Your library	French		PG3476 .B78	[2266062328]	2266062328, 9782266062329	Allegories|Bulgakov|Good and evil > Fiction|Humanities|Jerusalem > Fiction|Jesus Christ > Fiction|Literature|Mental illness > Fiction|Moscow (Russia) > Fiction|Novel|Pilate, Pontius, 1st cent. > Fiction|Political fiction|Russia > Fiction|Russian fiction|Russian publications (Form Entry)|Soviet Union > History > 1925-1953 > Fiction|literature	891.7342	1917-1945 > 1917-1991 (USSR) > Literature > Literature of other Indo-European languages > Other Languages > Russian > Russian Fiction		1	Amazon.fr	[2006-07-25]			10151				
+5015399	Le Maître et Marguerite	1	Boulgakov, Mikhaïl				Pocket (1994), Poche	1994					Le Maître et Marguerite by Mikhaïl Boulgakov (1994)	Broché	579 p.; 7.09 inches	0.66 pounds	7.09 inches	1.18 inches	4.33 inches	7.09 x 4.33 x 1.18 inches	579 								Your library	French		PG3476 .B78	[2266062328]	2266062328, 9782266062329	Allegories|Bulgakov|Good and evil > Fiction|Humanities|Jerusalem > Fiction|Jesus Christ > Fiction|Literature|Mental illness > Fiction|Moscow (Russia) > Fiction|Novel|Pilate, Pontius, 1st cent. > Fiction|Political fiction|Russia > Fiction|Russian fiction|Russian publications (Form Entry)|Soviet Union > History > 1925-1953 > Fiction|literature	891.7342	1917-1945 > 1917-1991 (USSR) > Literature > Literature of other Indo-European languages > Other Languages > Russian > Russian Fiction		1	Amazon.fr	[2006-07-25]			10151